crop unrecognizable businesswoman typing on laptop at homePhoto by EKATERINA BOLOVTSOVA on <a href="" rel="nofollow"></a>

How Do You Test and Set Pricing for a Paid Membership Site?

Launching a paid membership site is an exciting milestone, but determining the optimal pricing strategy can be challenging. What feels fair to you may deter sign-ups. Testing different price points informs data-driven decisions.

This comprehensive guide covers proven methods and key considerations when testing and setting pricing for paid membership site plans to maximize revenue. Let’s start with fundamental pricing frameworks.

Setting the right pricing for a paid membership site is crucial for the success of your online business. It requires careful consideration and testing to find the optimal pricing strategy that will attract and retain members while also generating revenue. In this article, we will explore different pricing strategies, factors to consider, and how to test and set pricing for your membership site.

Understanding Membership Sites

Before diving into pricing strategies, it’s important to have a clear understanding of what a membership website is and how it differs from a subscription website.

What is a Membership Website?

A membership website is a gated online platform that offers exclusive content, services, or products to its members. Users typically need to create an account and pay a fee to access the premium content or benefits.

Difference Between Membership & Subscription Websites

While both membership and subscription websites require users to pay for access, there is a key difference between the two. Membership websites often provide ongoing value and require recurring payments, while subscription websites generally offer access to a specific product or service for a limited period.

Pricing Frameworks for Membership Sites

Several pricing models provide helpful starting points when structuring membership site fees. Consider these frameworks:

Good-Better-Best Bundles

Offer tiered plans at low, medium and premium price points with graduated access to features, content, tools, downloads, and services at each level.

A La Carte Menu

Let members mix-and-match access to site sections, tools, courses, downloads, and other offerings individually priced on an itemized menu.


Make some sections, content samples or basic tools visible to non-members as “free trials”, while paid plans unlock full access and premium extras.

Pay-Per-Use Credits

For sites with diverse services like 1:1 video sessions or custom content, assign prepaid credit packs redeemable for personalized offerings.

Usage-Based Tiers

For membership sites focused on community building and engagement, structure broader pricing based on usage frequency like “casual”, “active”, or “power” user plans.

Group and Company Plans

Alongside individual plans, enable bulk discounted group, team, or company access plans based on number of seats.

Dynamic Pricing

For sites with tickets, live events, or demand-based services, adjust real-time prices responsively using algorithms based on timing, demand, and availability.

While these models provide helpful starting points, testing ultimately uncovers optimum pricing. Next let’s discuss things to test.

Key Factors to Test for Membership Pricing

Many variables impact ideal pricing. Test these elements systematically:

Price Points

Test a range of objectively cheap to expensive price points in $10-20 increments to determine sensitivity thresholds for each tiered plan.

Plan Structures

Try different combinations of features across plan levels. Assess whether more plans at lower costs perform better than fewer premium-priced plans.

Page Layouts

Alter the visual presentation of plans on pages, like horizontal tiers versus vertical features lists. Ensure clarity.

Plan Names and Copy

Evaluate whether perceived value stems from plan names like “Premium” or descriptive features. Test membership terminology.

Free Trial Periods

Offering 14-30 day free trials and freemium previews can help overcome resistance. Test trial period length.

Packages and Bundles

Bundle related mini course sequences, downloads or event access as fixed packages. Compare their appeal versus a la carte flexibility.

Guest Passes

Give members limited guest passes to invite friends for free trial periods. Monitor resulting conversions.

Customer Segments

Breakdown conversion and retention rates by customer personas, demographics, roles, usage levels, and interests to cater to highly-valued subsets.

Competitor Pricing

Benchmark plans against competitors. Test deviating above or below based on your brand distinction and market position.

Promotions and Discounts

Tempt sign-ups via special seasonal sales, first-time deals, and partner or loyalty discounts. Measure incremental conversions.

Robust testing reduces assumptions. Now let’s discuss pricing analysis to interpret results.

Analyzing Membership Pricing Tests

Crunching test data informs optimum pricing. Assess key metrics:

Sign-Up Conversions

Evaluate total membership conversions from prospects across each test plan and price point. Determine the volume tipping point.

Retention and Churn

Analyze cancellation and lapsed membership rates. Low churn signals appropriately priced plans members value long-term.

Usage Frequency

For metered sites, measure usage volumes correlated to price. Are more expensive plans engaging users proportionally?

Upgrade/Downgrade Activity

If offering plan changes, assess upgrade and downgrade trends. Frequent upgrading usually signals underpricing.

Revenue Per Member

Calculate average revenue generated per member based on plan level. Weigh revenue acceleration against potential attrition from higher pricing.

Customer Feedback

Survey members directly on perceived value. Would they pay more or less? Which features matter or feel overpriced?

Customer Service Volume

If demand is too high for personal interaction offered, reevaluate pricing and marketing volume accordingly.

Profit Margins

Determine profitability of each plan based on hard costs, overhead, taxes, and payment processing fees.

Thorough pricing analysis minimizes leaving money on the table or deterring sign-ups. Let’s now discuss additional factors influencing pricing strategy beyond testing.

Key Factors Influencing Membership Pricing

Testing provides data-driven guidance, but several other considerations factor into final pricing:

Market Positioning

Scope out competitor plan pricing along with your desired market positioning – low-cost provider, premium, middle ground, etc.

Brand Perception

Your existing brand reputation also sets expectations. Aspirational premium brands can typically command higher pricing.

Production Costs

Consider overhead, content creation, labor, systems, services, tools, taxes, and other costs required to deliver promised value per member.

Payment Provider Rates

The payment processor you use affects margins. Factor monthly and per transaction percentages and fees into pricing floors.

Lifetime Value

For long-term memberships, lifetime value beyond the initial subscription provides flexibility to price higher to acquire and retain high-volume users.

Plans vs Add-Ons

Balance base plan pricing with additional value-adding upgrades, services, coaching sessions, and other add-ons.

Platform Costs

Evaluate whether the membership site platform costs warrant passing on any portion of monthly or transaction fees to members.

Audience Demographics

Audiences in higher income brackets or professional roles used to paying for services may support elevated pricing.

While testing provides data-driven insights, these contextual factors help set optimal direction. Next let’s discuss pricing communication.

Communicating Pricing to Attract Members

Part of determining pricing involves framing perceived value. Strategic messaging helps justify costs:

Share Member Testimonials

Storytelling from delighted members validates value better than you simply stating it. Let their voices advocate.

Explain Member Benefits

List specific problems solved, services delivered, skills gained, and needs met through clear, detailed plan descriptions rather than vague overviews.

Showcase Deliverables

Communicate tangible things members receive, whether learning materials, 1:1 coaching, worksheets, templates, tools, or community access.

Highlight Your Expertise

Establish credentials and experience that support charging premium rates, like advanced certifications, media features, test results, and client outcomes.

Outline Exclusive Perks

Promote special bonuses, insider access, member discounts, networking opportunities, and VIP treatment only available to paid members.

Offer Warranties

Guaranteeing satisfaction, value, or outcomes demonstrates confidence in pricing. Consider a money-back period, price-match, or replacement policy.

Share Discounts Upfront

Being transparent around student, military, senior, affiliate/influencer, and seasonal specials builds trust versus suspecting hidden better deals.

Bill Annually

While allowing monthly payments, encourage annual plans that lock in longer commitments at discounted flat rates. This signals higher worth.

Effective pricing communication convinces members to take the leap and invest in your offering. Finally, let’s discuss frequently updating pricing.

Continually Evaluating and Adjusting Pricing

Pricing optimization never ends. As business conditions and market demands evolve, pricing should adjust:

Hone Pricing Over Time

Regularly test new price points, bundles, and promotions in small batches for existing plans or to expand your offering with new add-ons.

Adapt to Demand Shifts

Monitor spikes or declines in category interest, competitor actions, seasonal trends, and economic landscape shifts. Respond with pricing accordingly.

Reflect Operational Efficiencies

If you scale services, automate delivery, or reduce overhead, pass some savings to customers through lower pricing to stay competitive.

Account for Inflation

Gradually increase prices over time matching or just above inflation rates to offset rising operational costs. Adds value perception.

Reward Loyalty

Offer tenured subscribers pricing perks like loyalty discounts, legacy lower rates, or grandfathered benefits when adjusting new customer rates.

Track Market Rate Movement

Keep an eye on category and competitor rate movements when considering increases or decreases. Stick close to market ranges.

Motivate Desired Actions

Incentivize the most valued customer behaviors with pricing like discounts for referral sign-ups, annual renewals, add-on purchases or usage frequency.

Ongoing monitoring and optimization ensures pricing remains aligned to internal costs, customer perceptions, and market conditions long after launch.

Pricing Strategies for Membership Sites

Having a well-defined pricing strategy is essential for the success of your membership site. It helps you determine the right price point that will attract your target audience, cover your costs, and generate a profit.

Importance of a Pricing Strategy

A pricing strategy provides a framework for setting prices that align with your business goals and market demand. It helps you balance the perceived value of your offerings with your desired profit margin.

Different Pricing Strategies

There are several pricing strategies you can consider for your membership site:

  • Value-based pricing: Determine the price based on the perceived value of your offerings to the members.
  • Competitive pricing: Set prices based on the market rates to stay competitive.
  • Free trial and freemium model: Offer a free trial or a limited version of your membership site to attract potential customers.
  • Tiered pricing: Offer different membership levels with varying features and benefits at different price points.

Create a Pricing Strategy

To create an effective pricing strategy, consider the following factors:

  • Understand your target audience’s willingness to pay for your offerings.
  • Conduct market research to identify the prices of similar membership sites in your industry.
  • Calculate your costs, including the expenses associated with maintaining and growing your business.
  • Establish your profit margin goals.
  • Take into account any unique features or benefits your membership site provides.
  • Consider the perceived value of your offerings and the potential return on investment for your members.

Factors to Consider in Pricing

There are several important factors to consider when setting the prices for your membership site:

Pricing Model

Choose a pricing model that suits your membership site’s offerings and revenue goals. Common models include monthly, annual, or lifetime subscriptions.

Product Pricing

Determine the right price for your product or service by considering factors such as production costs, market demand, competition, and the perceived value it provides to your members.

Pricing Calculator

Using a pricing calculator can help you estimate the revenue and profitability of different pricing scenarios. It takes into account variables such as the number of members, the price per membership, and the duration of memberships.

Free Trials and Sale Prices

Offering free trials or periodic sale prices can be an effective way to attract new members or incentivize renewals. These promotions allow potential members to experience the value of your membership site before committing to a paid subscription.

Testing and Setting Pricing

Testing and optimizing your pricing strategy is an ongoing process. Here are some steps to follow:

Setting Up a Staging Site

Create a staging site where you can make changes to your membership site without affecting the live version. This allows you to test different pricing plans and strategies in a controlled environment.

Establishing Goals for the Staging Site

Clearly define your goals for the staging site, such as increasing sign-ups, improving member retention, or increasing revenue. Set specific targets that you want to achieve through pricing changes.

Using Pause Mode for Safe Setup

Use “pause mode” or similar features provided by your membership site platform to prevent new sign-ups while you make changes to your pricing plans. This ensures that existing members are not affected by any disruptions during the testing phase.

Moving Code Changes to Production

Once you have tested and fine-tuned your pricing plans on the staging site, it’s time to implement the changes on your live production site. Ensure a smooth transition by thoroughly testing the changes before making them live.

Testing Pricing Plans

Test different pricing plans and options to see how they affect user behavior. Monitor metrics such as conversion rates, customer churn, and revenue to evaluate the effectiveness of each pricing strategy.

Best Membership Site Plugins

Choosing the right membership site plugin is crucial for building and managing your membership site. Here are some popular WordPress membership plugins:

Overview of WordPress Membership Plugins

WordPress offers a wide range of membership plugins that provide various features and functionalities for your membership site. These plugins allow you to control access to content, manage subscriptions, and handle payments.

Top WordPress Membership Plugins

Some of the top WordPress membership plugins include:

  • Paid Memberships Pro
  • MemberPress
  • Restrict Content Pro
  • WooCommerce Memberships
  • MemberMouse


Pricing your membership site effectively is crucial for attracting and retaining members while also generating revenue. By understanding the different pricing strategies, considering important factors, and testing and setting pricing, you can optimize your pricing strategy and ensure the success of your paid membership site. Choose the right membership site platform and plugin for your specific needs, and continuously monitor and analyze the effectiveness of your pricing to adapt and improve over time.

Determining the right membership site pricing is crucial but requires testing and updating over time. Key takeaways:

  • Start with established frameworks like good-better-best bundles, dynamic pricing, or freemium models as a baseline.
  • Test price points, page layouts, plan structures, copywriting, discounts, customer segments, competitor pricing, and usage data.
  • Analyze sign-up rates, churn, revenue per member, upgrades and downgrades, usage levels, feedback, service demand, and profit margins.
  • Consider brand positioning, production costs, payment fees, lifetime value, audience demographics, and platform expenses when setting pricing.
  • Justify pricing through member stories, benefit explanations, credentials, exclusivity, warranties, discounts, and annual billing.
  • Continuously reevaluate pricing as you scale, tracking inflation, efficiency gains, market rates, loyalty perks, and demand shifts.

Setting the right membership pricing is a delicate balance between covering costs and attracting your ideal audience. Use testing and ongoing refinement based on market conditions and business factors to maximize revenue while delivering member value.


By Dani Davis

Dani Davis is the pen name of the writer of this blog with more 15 years of constant experience in Content marketing and informatics product, e-commerce niche.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *